Learning through experience and error

The Little Argument Of ‘An Year’ Or ‘A Year’

T
The Little Argument Of 'An Year' Or 'A Year'
Read the P.S. for my reasons for selecting this quote.

Not all of us find situations which potentially become the truest examples of old idioms, statements or lessons we heard as a child. I was fortunate enough today. After that little incident happened, I just wanted to write about it as soon as possible so I’m typing this from the place that is the library itself, I’ll publish it later from my laptop.


So, a few minutes ago, I was sitting in the library while my roommate sat across me and I heard a faint calling, somewhere around me, an argument was taking place and believe it or not, I’m all for arguments so much that I cannot avoid eavesdropping into one. So, the argument was as follows…

Girl1: Why do people say ‘a year’ when it’s clearly ‘an year’?

Girl2: Isn’t it ‘a year’?

Girl3: Haan yaar¹, it’s a Year. (Pardon the Hinglish, but that is how everyone talks here in India. I’ll explain all the words in the endnote.)

Girl4: *silent*

Meanwhile, everyone around was having their own version of Is it an Year or a Year? and so we joined in while I listened more. Girl1 goes on to explain further

Girl1: It isn’t the first letter yaar, it’s the sound that matters. For example, in the word Honest, the sound of comes first tabhi² it’s written as ‘an honest person’. Similarly, it’s ‘an year’ and not ‘a year’.

Although she was right on her logic she was wrong on her facts that the pronunciation of year and ear are different. She was totally right in saying it’s ‘an year’ if year was pronounced the same as ear but as it turns out, year has a totally different pronunciation.

Year (listen) is pronounced with the /ji/ sound while Ear (listen) is pronounced with the /i/ and that’s just the rough version of it.

The above was a beautiful, live example of the famous phrase,

A little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

This little incident really made me think whether we can really assume that what we are saying is correct based on how less often someone opposes us or knows more than us in that particular domain. It’s the naïvety of our nature to assume that we’re foremost. I didn’t correct the girl for I didn’t know her and, I didn’t want to sound like an intrusive jerk who (in this scenario) ironically, shows his knowledge off.

P.S. While I was searching for an appropriate quote for the featured image of this post, I learned that this famous phrase is actually a misquote from An Essay on Criticism by Alexander Pope and that the true meaning got lost when someone used it out of context. Nevertheless, although it was misinterpreted, it became a lesson for all future generations to come.

¹Yaar: Friend
²tabhi: which is why / then

About the author

Deepansh Khurana

Blogger and writer from Dehradun, India. I'd say I love coffee but don't we all? I find stories, people and experiences. I blog about them.

Add comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

By Deepansh Khurana
Learning through experience and error

About The Content

There are two kinds of blog posts here as of mid-2018 – The Journal and The Words.

The Journals are thoughts, lessons, events that unfold in my life word-for-word and as barebones as I can put them out there.

The Words are creative pieces, narratives, short-stories that take from my life but did not happen word-for-word.

You can read more about this change here.

Like what you see?

Enter your email address below to get blog posts in your inbox as soon as I hit "Publish".

Join 812 other subscribers.

Deepansh Khurana

Blogger and writer from Dehradun, India. I'd say I love coffee but don't we all? I find stories, people and experiences. I blog about them.

Follow

You can follow the blog or me on these social channels. Instagram is where I post musings along with decent photographs so that is the only one I'll urge you to check out.

Instagram

Blog Archive

This Week, That Year

%d bloggers like this: